CVE-2023-52894

In the Linux kernel, the following vulnerability has been resolved:

usb: gadget: f_ncm: fix potential NULL ptr deref in ncm_bitrate()

In Google internal bug 265639009 we've received an (as yet) unreproducible
crash report from an aarch64 GKI 5.10.149-android13 running device.

AFAICT the source code is at:
  https://android.googlesource.com/kernel/common/+/refs/tags/ASB-2022-12-05_13-5.10

The call stack is:
  ncm_close() -> ncm_notify() -> ncm_do_notify()
with the crash at:
  ncm_do_notify+0x98/0x270
Code: 79000d0b b9000a6c f940012a f9400269 (b9405d4b)

Which I believe disassembles to (I don't know ARM assembly, but it looks sane enough to me...):

  // halfword (16-bit) store presumably to event->wLength (at offset 6 of struct usb_cdc_notification)
  0B 0D 00 79    strh w11, [x8, #6]

  // word (32-bit) store presumably to req->Length (at offset 8 of struct usb_request)
  6C 0A 00 B9    str  w12, [x19, #8]

  // x10 (NULL) was read here from offset 0 of valid pointer x9
  // IMHO we're reading 'cdev->gadget' and getting NULL
  // gadget is indeed at offset 0 of struct usb_composite_dev
  2A 01 40 F9    ldr  x10, [x9]

  // loading req->buf pointer, which is at offset 0 of struct usb_request
  69 02 40 F9    ldr  x9, [x19]

  // x10 is null, crash, appears to be attempt to read cdev->gadget->max_speed
  4B 5D 40 B9    ldr  w11, [x10, #0x5c]

which seems to line up with ncm_do_notify() case NCM_NOTIFY_SPEED code fragment:

  event->wLength = cpu_to_le16(8);
  req->length = NCM_STATUS_BYTECOUNT;

  /* SPEED_CHANGE data is up/down speeds in bits/sec */
  data = req->buf + sizeof *event;
  data[0] = cpu_to_le32(ncm_bitrate(cdev->gadget));

My analysis of registers and NULL ptr deref crash offset
  (Unable to handle kernel NULL pointer dereference at virtual address 000000000000005c)
heavily suggests that the crash is due to 'cdev->gadget' being NULL when executing:
  data[0] = cpu_to_le32(ncm_bitrate(cdev->gadget));
which calls:
  ncm_bitrate(NULL)
which then calls:
  gadget_is_superspeed(NULL)
which reads
  ((struct usb_gadget *)NULL)->max_speed
and hits a panic.

AFAICT, if I'm counting right, the offset of max_speed is indeed 0x5C.
(remember there's a GKI KABI reservation of 16 bytes in struct work_struct)

It's not at all clear to me how this is all supposed to work...
but returning 0 seems much better than panic-ing...
ProviderTypeBase ScoreAtk. VectorAtk. ComplexityPriv. RequiredVector
NISTNIST
5.5 MEDIUM
LOCAL
LOW
LOW
CVSS:3.1/AV:L/AC:L/PR:L/UI:N/S:U/C:N/I:N/A:H
LinuxCNA
---
---
CISA-ADPADP
---
---
Base Score
CVSS 3.x
EPSS Score
Percentile: 9%
VendorProductVersion
linuxlinux_kernel
𝑥
< 4.14.304
linuxlinux_kernel
4.15 ≤
𝑥
< 4.19.271
linuxlinux_kernel
4.20 ≤
𝑥
< 5.4.230
linuxlinux_kernel
5.5 ≤
𝑥
< 5.10.165
linuxlinux_kernel
5.11 ≤
𝑥
< 5.15.90
linuxlinux_kernel
5.16 ≤
𝑥
< 6.1.8
linuxlinux_kernel
6.2:rc1
linuxlinux_kernel
6.2:rc2
linuxlinux_kernel
6.2:rc3
linuxlinux_kernel
6.2:rc4
𝑥
= Vulnerable software versions
Debian logo
Debian Releases
Debian Product
Codename
linux
bullseye
5.10.223-1
fixed
bullseye (security)
5.10.226-1
fixed
bookworm
6.1.115-1
fixed
bookworm (security)
6.1.119-1
fixed
sid
6.12.6-1
fixed
trixie
6.12.6-1
fixed
Ubuntu logo
Ubuntu Releases
Ubuntu Product
Codename
linux
oracular
not-affected
noble
not-affected
jammy
Fixed 5.15.0-70.77
released
focal
Fixed 5.4.0-147.164
released
bionic
Fixed 4.15.0-209.220
released
xenial
ignored
trusty
ignored
linux-allwinner-5.19
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
ignored
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-aws
oracular
not-affected
noble
not-affected
jammy
Fixed 5.15.0-1034.38
released
focal
Fixed 5.4.0-1100.108
released
bionic
Fixed 4.15.0-1154.167
released
xenial
ignored
trusty
ignored
linux-aws-5.0
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
dne
bionic
ignored
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-aws-5.11
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
ignored
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-aws-5.13
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
ignored
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-aws-5.15
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
Fixed 5.15.0-1034.38~20.04.1
released
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-aws-5.19
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
ignored
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-aws-5.3
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
dne
bionic
ignored
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-aws-5.4
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
dne
bionic
Fixed 5.4.0-1100.108~18.04.1
released
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-aws-5.8
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
ignored
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-aws-6.2
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
ignored
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-aws-6.5
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
ignored
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-aws-6.8
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
not-affected
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-aws-fips
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
ignored
trusty
dne
linux-aws-hwe
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
Fixed 4.15.0-1154.167~16.04.1
released
trusty
dne
linux-azure
oracular
not-affected
noble
not-affected
jammy
Fixed 5.15.0-1036.43
released
focal
Fixed 5.4.0-1106.112
released
bionic
ignored
xenial
Fixed 4.15.0-1163.178~16.04.1
released
trusty
Fixed 4.15.0-1163.178~14.04.1
released
linux-azure-4.15
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
dne
bionic
Fixed 4.15.0-1163.178
released
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-azure-5.11
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
ignored
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-azure-5.13
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
ignored
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-azure-5.15
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
Fixed 5.15.0-1036.43~20.04.1
released
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-azure-5.19
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
ignored
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-azure-5.3
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
dne
bionic
ignored
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-azure-5.4
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
dne
bionic
Fixed 5.4.0-1106.112~18.04.1
released
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-azure-5.8
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
ignored
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-azure-6.2
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
ignored
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-azure-6.5
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
ignored
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-azure-6.8
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
not-affected
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-azure-edge
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
dne
bionic
ignored
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-azure-fde
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
Fixed 5.15.0-1036.43.1
released
focal
ignored
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-azure-fde-5.15
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
Fixed 5.15.0-1036.43~20.04.1.1
released
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-azure-fde-5.19
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
ignored
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-azure-fde-6.2
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
ignored
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-azure-fips
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
ignored
trusty
dne
linux-bluefield
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
Fixed 5.4.0-1062.68
released
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-fips
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-gcp
oracular
not-affected
noble
not-affected
jammy
Fixed 5.15.0-1032.40
released
focal
Fixed 5.4.0-1103.112
released
bionic
ignored
xenial
Fixed 4.15.0-1148.164~16.04.1
released
trusty
dne
linux-gcp-4.15
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
dne
bionic
Fixed 4.15.0-1148.164
released
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-gcp-5.11
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
ignored
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-gcp-5.13
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
ignored
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-gcp-5.15
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
Fixed 5.15.0-1032.40~20.04.1
released
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-gcp-5.19
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
ignored
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-gcp-5.3
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
dne
bionic
ignored
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-gcp-5.4
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
dne
bionic
Fixed 5.4.0-1103.112~18.04.1
released
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-gcp-5.8
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
ignored
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-gcp-6.2
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
ignored
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-gcp-6.5
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
ignored
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-gcp-6.8
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
not-affected
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-gcp-fips
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
ignored
trusty
dne
linux-gke
oracular
dne
noble
not-affected
jammy
Fixed 5.15.0-1031.36
released
focal
ignored
bionic
dne
xenial
ignored
trusty
dne
linux-gke-4.15
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
dne
bionic
ignored
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-gke-5.15
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
ignored
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-gke-5.4
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
dne
bionic
ignored
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-gkeop
oracular
dne
noble
not-affected
jammy
Fixed 5.15.0-1018.23
released
focal
Fixed 5.4.0-1067.71
released
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-gkeop-5.15
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
Fixed 5.15.0-1018.23~20.04.1
released
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-gkeop-5.4
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
dne
bionic
ignored
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-hwe
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
dne
bionic
ignored
xenial
Fixed 4.15.0-209.220~16.04.1
released
trusty
dne
linux-hwe-5.11
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
ignored
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-hwe-5.13
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
ignored
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-hwe-5.15
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
Fixed 5.15.0-70.77~20.04.1
released
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-hwe-5.19
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
ignored
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-hwe-5.4
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
dne
bionic
Fixed 5.4.0-147.164~18.04.1
released
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-hwe-5.8
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
ignored
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-hwe-6.2
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
ignored
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-hwe-6.5
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
ignored
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-hwe-6.8
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
not-affected
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-hwe-edge
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
dne
bionic
ignored
xenial
ignored
trusty
dne
linux-ibm
oracular
dne
noble
not-affected
jammy
Fixed 5.15.0-1028.31
released
focal
Fixed 5.4.0-1047.52
released
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-ibm-5.15
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
not-affected
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-ibm-5.4
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
dne
bionic
Fixed 5.4.0-1047.52~18.04.1
released
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-intel
oracular
dne
noble
not-affected
jammy
dne
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-intel-5.13
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
ignored
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-intel-iot-realtime
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-intel-iotg
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
Fixed 5.15.0-1028.33
released
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-intel-iotg-5.15
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
Fixed 5.15.0-1030.35~20.04.1
released
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-iot
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
Fixed 5.4.0-1017.18
released
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-kvm
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
Fixed 5.15.0-1031.36
released
focal
Fixed 5.4.0-1089.95
released
bionic
Fixed 4.15.0-1138.143
released
xenial
ignored
trusty
dne
linux-lowlatency
oracular
not-affected
noble
not-affected
jammy
Fixed 5.15.0-70.77
released
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-lowlatency-hwe-5.15
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
Fixed 5.15.0-70.77~20.04.1
released
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-lowlatency-hwe-5.19
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
ignored
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-lowlatency-hwe-6.2
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
ignored
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-lowlatency-hwe-6.5
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
ignored
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-lowlatency-hwe-6.8
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
not-affected
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-lts-xenial
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
ignored
linux-nvidia
oracular
dne
noble
not-affected
jammy
Fixed 5.15.0-1023.23
released
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-nvidia-6.2
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
ignored
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-nvidia-6.5
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
not-affected
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-nvidia-6.8
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
not-affected
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-nvidia-lowlatency
oracular
dne
noble
not-affected
jammy
dne
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-oem
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
dne
bionic
ignored
xenial
ignored
trusty
dne
linux-oem-5.10
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
ignored
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-oem-5.13
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
ignored
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-oem-5.14
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
ignored
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-oem-5.17
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
ignored
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-oem-5.6
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
ignored
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-oem-6.0
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
ignored
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-oem-6.1
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
ignored
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-oem-6.11
oracular
dne
noble
not-affected
jammy
dne
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-oem-6.5
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
ignored
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-oem-6.8
oracular
dne
noble
not-affected
jammy
dne
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-oracle
oracular
not-affected
noble
not-affected
jammy
Fixed 5.15.0-1033.39
released
focal
Fixed 5.4.0-1099.108
released
bionic
Fixed 4.15.0-1117.128
released
xenial
Fixed 4.15.0-1117.128~16.04.1
released
trusty
dne
linux-oracle-5.0
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
dne
bionic
ignored
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-oracle-5.11
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
ignored
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-oracle-5.13
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
ignored
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-oracle-5.15
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
Fixed 5.15.0-1033.39~20.04.1
released
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-oracle-5.3
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
dne
bionic
ignored
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-oracle-5.4
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
dne
bionic
Fixed 5.4.0-1099.108~18.04.1
released
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-oracle-5.8
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
ignored
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-oracle-6.5
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
ignored
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-oracle-6.8
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
not-affected
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-raspi
oracular
not-affected
noble
not-affected
jammy
Fixed 5.15.0-1027.29
released
focal
Fixed 5.4.0-1083.94
released
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-raspi-5.4
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
dne
bionic
Fixed 5.4.0-1083.94~18.04.1
released
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-raspi-realtime
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-raspi2
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
ignored
bionic
ignored
xenial
ignored
trusty
dne
linux-realtime
oracular
not-affected
noble
dne
jammy
ignored
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-riscv
oracular
not-affected
noble
not-affected
jammy
ignored
focal
ignored
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-riscv-5.11
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
ignored
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-riscv-5.15
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
Fixed 5.15.0-1031.35~20.04.1
released
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-riscv-5.19
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
ignored
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-riscv-5.8
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
dne
focal
ignored
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-riscv-6.5
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
ignored
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-riscv-6.8
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
not-affected
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-starfive-5.19
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
ignored
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-starfive-6.2
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
ignored
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-starfive-6.5
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
ignored
focal
dne
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne
linux-xilinx-zynqmp
oracular
dne
noble
dne
jammy
not-affected
focal
Fixed 5.4.0-1024.28
released
bionic
dne
xenial
dne
trusty
dne